Discover how to beautifully remodel historic homes in some of Phoenix and Scottsdale’s most charming neighborhoods, including FQ Story, Coronado, and Willo. We delve into the unique design considerations and challenges that come with preserving the character and history of these homes while updating them for modern living. Whether you're looking to restore original architectural features or seamlessly blend old-world charm with contemporary luxury, we provide expert insights on making your historic home remodel a success.

Historic Neighborhoods of Downtown Phoenix

FQ Story: A Tapestry of 1920s and 1930s Charm

FQ Story, one of Phoenix’s earliest historic districts, began its development in the 1920s and continued into the 1930s. This neighborhood is a testament to the rich history of Phoenix, reflecting a time when the city was just beginning to expand. The homes here are predominantly Bungalows, English Tudors, and Spanish Colonial Revivals, each style contributing to the unique architectural fabric of the neighborhood.

Influential Architects and Features to Preserve

Key architects like C. Lewis Kelley and R.A. Gray left their mark on FQ Story, designing homes that have stood the test of time. The Bungalows, with their low-pitched roofs and wide porches, often feature intricate woodwork and built-ins that are quintessential elements worth preserving. Spanish Colonial homes, on the other hand, boast stucco exteriors, arched doorways, and red-tiled roofs, all of which add to the neighborhood's distinct aesthetic. Restoring these features, such as the original wooden floors, vintage light fixtures, and detailed plasterwork, is crucial in maintaining the historic integrity of these homes.

Images courtesy of Story Preservation Association. You can learn more about the FQ Story neighborhood at their upcoming Home Tour & Holiday Market on December 7, 2024.

Coronado: A Blend of Early 20th Century Styles

Coronado, another iconic historic district in Phoenix, developed primarily between the 1920s and 1940s. This neighborhood is known for its eclectic mix of architectural styles, ranging from California Bungalows and Spanish Colonials to Ranch-style homes and the more modest Transitional Ranches that became popular in the post-World War II era.

Influential Architects and Features to Preserve

While Coronado didn’t have a single dominant architect, the neighborhood reflects the broader architectural trends of the early 20th century. The California Bungalows in Coronado are known for their craftsman details, such as exposed rafters, wide front porches, and built-in cabinetry. These homes often feature original hardwood floors, brick fireplaces, and large, multi-pane windows that are essential to the character of the property. Preserving these features, along with the stucco facades and tile work of the Spanish Colonial homes, ensures that the charm and history of Coronado continue to shine through.

The Coronado Neighborhood Association hosts the Coronado Historically Modern Home Tour, scheduled for February 23, 2025.

Willo: A Showcase of 1930s and 1940s Elegance

The Willo Historic District is perhaps the most well-known of Phoenix’s historic neighborhoods, with development dating from the 1920s through the 1940s. Originally a citrus grove, Willo transformed into a residential area that now features a range of architectural styles, including Tudor Revivals, Spanish Colonials, and later, Ranch-style homes. Willo’s wide streets, lined with mature trees, create a picturesque setting for these beautifully crafted homes.

Influential Architects and Features to Preserve

Architects like Charles Barnes and Lescher & Mahoney played a role in shaping the architectural landscape of Willo. Tudor Revival homes in Willo are characterized by steeply pitched gable roofs, decorative half-timbering, and arched doorways. The Spanish Colonial homes are distinguished by their white stucco walls, terracotta roofs, and wrought-iron accents. Many homes in Willo also feature original wood windows, built-in niches, and custom tile work, all of which are key elements to preserve during a remodel. These features not only enhance the aesthetic appeal but also serve as a nod to the home’s historical roots.

Did we meet at the 2024 Willo Home Tour? Our Soulful Sanctuary project was featured there! Image by Agnes Art & Photo. You can attend their next home tour on February 16, 2025.

Why Hiring a Professional Interior Designer is Essential

At Mackenzie Collier Interiors, we understand that remodeling a historic home is both an art and a science. Our extensive experience working with historic properties across Phoenix’s iconic neighborhoods, including FQ Story, Coronado, and Willo, equips us with the expertise needed to strike the perfect balance between preservation and modernization.

Here are five tips from our team on how to approach your historic home remodel…

1. Prioritize Structural Integrity

   Before diving into the aesthetics, ensure that the home’s structural elements, such as the foundation, roof, and walls, are sound. Historic homes often come with hidden issues like outdated wiring, plumbing, or even foundation cracks. Addressing these first prevents future complications and allows you to focus on the design elements with peace of mind.

2. Respect and Restore Original Features

   One of the most valuable aspects of a historic home is its original architectural features. Whether it's a vintage fireplace, hardwood floors, or intricate moldings, strive to restore rather than replace these elements. If original materials are too damaged, consider sourcing salvaged materials that match the period to maintain authenticity.

3. Incorporate Modern Conveniences Discreetly

   Modernizing a historic home doesn’t mean compromising its character. Incorporate contemporary conveniences, like smart home technology or updated HVAC systems, in ways that don’t detract from the home’s period charm. For instance, hide new wiring behind walls, use period-appropriate switch plates, or install slimline radiators that blend with the decor.

4. Choose Paint Colors Thoughtfully

   The right color palette can make a significant difference in how the space feels while remaining true to the home’s historical period. Consider using colors that were popular in the era when the home was built, or modern neutrals that complement the home’s original materials and features. For example, earth tones or muted shades work well in Spanish Colonial Revivals, while cooler hues can enhance the sophistication of a Tudor.

5. Enhance Curb Appeal with Period-Appropriate Landscaping

   The exterior of your historic home is just as important as the interior. When planning your remodel, include period-appropriate landscaping that complements the home’s architecture. For instance, a Spanish Colonial might benefit from Mediterranean-style gardens with drought-tolerant plants, while a Tudor home might look best with a more formal, English-inspired garden. Don’t forget to restore or replicate original exterior features like shutters, gates, and lighting fixtures to complete the look.

Our Proven Track Record in Historic Preservation

Mackenzie Collier Interiors has had the privilege of working on some of Phoenix’s most notable historic renovation projects. We’ve completed remodels in all three of the historic districts mentioned, ensuring that each project preserves the original charm of the home while seamlessly integrating modern conveniences. Our work on the DeSoto Central Market building—a project that transformed a former DeSoto Car dealership from disrepair into a vibrant community space—showcases our commitment to breathing new life into historic properties.

We also specialize in adaptive reuse projects, such as converting a 1940s paper distribution warehouse in the Phoenix warehouse district into modern offices for Equality Health, and revitalizing a historic church in Old Town Scottsdale to serve as the headquarters for Lemonade Insurance. These projects exemplify our ability to honor a building’s history while adapting it for contemporary use.

When you choose Mackenzie Collier Interiors, you’re not just hiring an interior designer—you’re partnering with a team that understands the nuances of historic preservation and the importance of creating spaces that are as functional as they are beautiful. Let us help you transform your historic home into a space that perfectly blends the past with the present.